How a company cashed in on anthrax
The
vaccine maker's frequent cries for help brought it millions of
additional tax dollars - even when it could not deliver a product that
troops could use.
December 7, 2005
In a two-year span, the nation's only licensed anthrax vaccine maker
went from pleading poverty to announcing $100 million in acquisitions,
including other pharmaceutical companies and a new manufacturing plant
near Washington, D.C.
It's a pattern that's worked well for BioPort Corp.: Tell the Pentagon
or Congress that it doesn't have the money to keep going, negotiate a
new deal, then count the extra cash rolling in.
During the past seven years, it's transformed an initial investment of
less than $4.5 million into an international biotech firm, with
contracts worth more than $450 million. During that time, the company
has capitalized on its monopoly over the vaccine and on fears that
opposing armies and terrorists will unleash tiny anthrax spores
somewhere.
BioPort is an example of how a sole-source government contract can
become a gold mine - especially if you spend wisely on the right
lobbyists and public relations professionals.
BioPort counts a former Cabinet member and assistant secretary of
health and human services among those it pays to gain favor with
government agencies.
"You always pay a higher price when you're stuck with a sole-source,"
says Philip Coyle, a former assistant secretary of defense for
procurement. "The government has nowhere else to go if it wants what
you have to sell."
He says Pentagon officials talked about taking over the anthrax vaccine
plant and operations - especially after the government held the license
for the vaccine as collateral for a series of loans and payments that
kept the company afloat.
"What I never heard in those discussions was why nothing ever came of it," he says.
The Pentagon isn't telling that story, and neither is BioPort.
MOST BIOPORT FINANCES AREN'T OPEN TO PUBLIC
Troops and veterans who've been asked to put BioPort's products in
their bodies often point to the company's problems getting a clean bill
of health for its manufacturing plant, as well as to the company's
ability to always get its way with government officials. They wonder
whether BioPort's connections - not its scientific and medical prowess
- are behind the company's success.
BioPort is a privately held company that doesn't make its stock
available for public sale. As a result, most aspects of its finances
and management aren't open to public scrutiny.
The company declined to provide its officers for interviews with the
Daily Press. Six weeks after receiving a list of detailed questions -
and promising answers - it sent a box containing two books and some
news releases. None of the questions was answered.
BioPort's approach to veterans is similar: It sends substitutes to
speak for it, often without disclosing that those sources were paid by
the company. Those surrogates disregard evidence of deaths or severe
health problems from the vaccine, and they provide testimony to
government regulators and the public.
Meanwhile, the veterans who think that they've been harmed by the vaccine live on disability payments or suffer in silence.
No government grants support research into their questions about the shot.
EX-JOINT CHIEFS HEAD WAS NAMED DIRECTOR
Until 1998, the nation's only manufacturing plant for anthrax
vaccine was owned and operated by the state of Michigan. The state
agency that ran the plant was losing money, so the state put the
operation and its license for making the anthrax vaccine up for bid.
Fuad El-Hibri, a 40-year-old German businessman with a Yale University
management degree, formed a team of investors to buy the business,
which included a $100 million contract with the Pentagon.
His bid faced a problem, though: He and his father, Ibrahim El-Hibri, a
wealthy international financier from Lebanon, dominated ownership of
the company, which they named BioPort.
Get home delivery of the Daily Press for less than $3.33 a week.